You’ve probably experienced the frustration of walking into a craft store only to find they’re out of the exact shade you need for your half-finished sweater. Shopping for yarn online solves this problem, but with countless retailers competing for your attention, you’ll want to know which ones actually deserve your time and money. We’ve tested the most popular options to help you find stores that match your specific needs.
Lion Brand Yarn Feels Like Butta Yarn for Crocheting and Knitting
If you’re searching for yarn that combines luxurious softness with practical durability, Lion Brand’s Feels Like Butta delivers both in a budget-friendly package. This 100% polyester worsted weight yarn offers 218 yards per 3.5-ounce skein, perfect for sweaters, scarves, and baby blankets. You’ll appreciate its velvety texture that works beautifully with size 7 knitting needles or G-6 crochet hooks. With 4.6 stars from over 8,000 reviews, crafters praise its resistance to fraying and pilling. Machine wash on gentle and tumble dry low—no ironing needed. Available in pastel and fashion colors, it’s ideal for beginners and experienced crafters alike.
Best For: Crafters of all skill levels who want a soft, easy-care yarn for clothing and home projects like sweaters, scarves, and baby blankets at an affordable price.
Pros:
- Supersoft, velvety texture that resists fraying, splitting, and pilling even after washing
- Machine washable and dryable with no ironing required for hassle-free care
- Highly rated (4.6 out of 5 stars from over 8,000 reviews) with consistent performance across various projects
Cons:
- Skein size is relatively small at 3.5 ounces, requiring multiple purchases for larger projects
- Dyelots are only guaranteed consistent for pack purchases, not individual skeins
- Customers wish for larger bulk packs at better price points to improve value
Lion Brand Yarn, Multicolor Ferris Wheel Yarn for Knitting and Crocheting
Lion Brand’s Multicolor Ferris Wheel Yarn transforms ordinary projects into eye-catching creations through its self-striping colorways and subtle ombre effect—making it the ideal choice for knitters and crocheters who want stunning color shifts without the hassle of changing yarns. This 100% acrylic worsted weight yarn offers 270 yards per 3-ounce skein, providing ample yardage for blankets, scarves, and sweaters. You’ll appreciate its soft texture and machine-washable care instructions. With 4.6 out of 5 stars from nearly 7,000 ratings, it’s earned its #43 ranking in yarn sales. Just handle it carefully when undoing stitches, as it tends to tangle and split.
Best For: Knitters and crocheters seeking self-striping colorways with automatic ombre effects for blankets, scarves, shawls, and sweaters without needing to manually change yarns.
Pros:
- Self-striping design creates beautiful color transitions automatically, eliminating the need to switch between multiple yarn colors
- Machine washable and tumble dry low care makes it practical for everyday wearable items and blankets
- Soft 100% acrylic texture with 270 yards per skein provides ample yardage at an affordable price point
Cons:
- Tends to tangle easily when undoing stitches, requiring careful handling during project corrections
- Yarn can split while working, which may frustrate beginners or those working on intricate stitch patterns
- Individual skeins may have inconsistent dye lots unless purchased in multi-packs, potentially affecting color matching for larger projects
LEMESO Acrylic Yarn for Crocheting (12 x 15g Multicolor Skeins)
The LEMESO 12 x 15g Acrylic Yarn collection serves crafters who value variety and affordability in their projects. You’ll receive twelve vibrant skeins totaling 393 yards of 100% acrylic yarn in colors including white, yellow, red, pink, green, orange, dark green, blue, dark blue, black, purple, and magenta. This soft, colorfast yarn won’t fade or shrink after washing and works perfectly with 5.5mm needles or hooks. You can create scarves, hats, shawls, shoes, garments, socks, and gloves. While the small 15g skeins limit larger projects, they’re excellent for children’s crafts and beginners. With 3.9 stars from 433 ratings, customers appreciate the vibrant colors despite packaging concerns.
Best For: Beginners, children, and crafting enthusiasts looking for an affordable multi-color yarn set for small projects like children’s crafts, accessories, and learning basic knitting or crocheting techniques.
Pros:
- Twelve vibrant, colorfast colors that won’t fade or shrink, offering excellent variety for creative projects
- Machine washable 100% acrylic material that’s soft and easy to care for
- Budget-friendly option ideal for practice, small projects, and introducing children to crafting
Cons:
- Small 15g skeins (only 33 yards each) limit use for larger projects and require frequent color changes
- Packaging concerns and quality issues noted by customers make it less suitable for professional-grade knitting
- Limited yardage per skein may not be cost-effective for crafters needing substantial amounts of single colors
100% Merino Wool Yarn, 6-Ply for Knitting & Crocheting (Morandi Blue, 1 Ball)
Crafters seeking premium softness and durability will find Gisimo’s 100% Merino Wool Yarn an excellent choice for their next knitting or crocheting project. This 6-ply Morandi Blue yarn delivers 127 yards per 1.76-ounce ball, sourced from Merino sheep renowned for exceptional softness and breathability. You’ll appreciate its reduced breakage risk and compatibility with 4-8mm needles. With 4.4 stars from 537 ratings and ranking #82 in yarn sales, it’s proven popular among crafters. Hand wash in cold water (max 86°F) and dry horizontally. Some users note occasional splitting and thickness inconsistencies, so consider ordering extra for larger projects.
Best For: Crafters who prioritize premium softness and durability in their knitting or crocheting projects and are willing to hand-wash their finished items.
Pros:
- Exceptionally soft, luxurious 100% Merino wool with excellent breathability and warmth
- Strong 6-ply construction reduces breakage risk during knitting or crocheting
- Highly rated (4.4/5 stars from 537 reviews) and ranked #82 in yarn category, demonstrating popularity and reliability
Cons:
- Requires hand washing in cold water and horizontal drying, which is more time-consuming than machine care
- Some users report issues with yarn splitting and inconsistencies in thickness
- At 1.76 oz per ball, you may need multiple balls for larger projects, potentially increasing costs
Red Heart Super Saver Purple Tones Yarn (3 Pack, 141g/5oz)
Red Heart Super Saver Purple Tones Yarn stands out as an exceptional choice for budget-conscious crafters who refuse to compromise on quality or versatility. This 100% acrylic worsted weight yarn comes in a convenient 3-pack, with each ball containing 141g and 236 yards. You’ll appreciate its OEKO-TEX Standard 100 certification, ensuring it’s free from over 300 harmful substances. The machine-washable, durable yarn maintains its integrity through countless wash cycles, making it ideal for everyday items. With a stellar 4.7-star rating from over 7,650 customers and ranking #5 in the yarn category, it’s trusted by America’s favorite yarn brand for over 30 years.
Best For: Budget-conscious crafters seeking a versatile, durable, and machine-washable yarn for everyday projects like blankets, garments, and home décor items.
Pros:
- OEKO-TEX Standard 100 certified, ensuring the yarn is free from over 300 harmful substances, making it safe for all users including babies
- Excellent value with a 3-pack option and machine-washable durability that maintains quality through countless wash cycles
- Trusted brand with outstanding customer satisfaction (4.7 out of 5 stars from 7,650+ ratings) and ranked #5 in the yarn category
Cons:
- Color variations and texture inconsistencies reported between different batches, which may affect larger projects requiring multiple packs
- Shorter yardage (236 yards per ball) for multi-color variants compared to solid colors (364 yards), requiring more skeins for bigger projects
- 100% acrylic composition may not appeal to crafters preferring natural fibers for breathability or eco-friendly considerations
Lion Brand Yarn 640-123E Wool-Ease Thick & Quick Yarn, Oatmeal
Lion Brand’s Wool-Ease Thick & Quick Yarn in Oatmeal stands out as an ideal choice for crafters who want to complete projects quickly without sacrificing quality. This super bulky yarn combines 82% acrylic, 10% wool, and 8% rayon, delivering softness and durability you’ll appreciate. Each 6-ounce skein provides 106 yards, perfect for blankets, sweaters, and home decor. You’ll work with US Size 13 needles or M/N-13 crochet hooks, making progress fast. It’s machine washable and maintains consistent color throughout. With 4.7 stars from nearly 12,000 customers, it’s ranked #6 in yarn sales, proving its reliability for crafters.
Best For: Crafters of all skill levels who want to complete large projects like blankets, sweaters, and home decor items quickly while enjoying soft, durable, machine-washable yarn.
Pros:
- Super bulky weight works up quickly with large needles or hooks, making it ideal for fast project completion
- Machine washable and dryable at low temperatures, offering easy care and maintenance for finished items
- Highly rated by nearly 12,000 customers with consistent softness, durability, and color throughout skeins
Cons:
- Some customers report finding knots in the yarn that can disrupt project workflow
- Considered expensive by some buyers compared to other yarn options
- Cannot be ironed, which may limit finishing options for certain projects
Lion Brand Yarn Hometown Yarn, Super-Bulky Yarn for Knitting and Crocheting
Super-bulky weight enthusiasts will find their perfect match in Lion Brand Yarn’s Hometown collection, a 100% acrylic yarn that transforms into cozy projects with remarkable speed. Each 5-ounce skein delivers 81 yards of soft, thick fiber that works beautifully with size 13 needles or N-13 hooks. You’ll appreciate the variety of solid colors, tweeds, and multicolor options that add visual interest to scarves, blankets, and sweaters. The yarn’s machine-washable, tumble-dry-friendly care makes it practical for everyday items. With 11,386 customer ratings averaging 4.6 stars, crafters praise its vibrant colors and ease of use, though some note occasional shedding during projects.
Best For: Crafters seeking a soft, budget-friendly super-bulky yarn for quick-working projects like blankets, scarves, and sweaters that need to be machine washable.
Pros:
- Works up quickly with large needles or hooks, making it ideal for fast project completion
- Machine washable and tumble dry safe, perfect for practical everyday items and gifts
- Wide variety of colors including solids, tweeds, and multicolors with vibrant appearance
Cons:
- Some users report shedding issues during use and after completion
- Strands may separate while working, requiring extra attention during crafting
- Relatively short yardage per skein (81 yards) may require multiple skeins for larger projects
Factors to Consider When Choosing an Online Yarn Store
When you’re shopping for yarn online, you’ll need to evaluate several key factors before committing to a store. Start by examining the quality and variety of yarns available, comparing prices across different retailers, and calculating the true cost including shipping fees. You should also review the store’s return policies and verify that product descriptions accurately reflect fiber content, weight, and yardage.
Yarn Quality and Variety
Quality and variety form the foundation of a successful yarn shopping experience, especially when you’re browsing online stores where you can’t physically touch the fibers. Look for retailers offering diverse materials—from 100% polyester and acrylic to luxurious merino wool—to match your project requirements. Detailed specifications matter: check for clear yarn weight classifications like CYC #4 medium or CYC #6 super bulky to guarantee compatibility with your patterns.
You’ll want stores featuring multiple colorways and textures, including self-striping yarns and pastel palettes that elevate your creations. Prioritize easy-care options with straightforward washing instructions, like machine washability and low-temperature drying. Finally, review customer feedback on softness, durability, and resistance to fraying or pilling—these factors directly influence your finished project’s quality.
Price and Value Comparison
Finding the perfect yarn means little if it strains your budget or delivers poor value. You’ll want to compare unit prices per yard, since longer skeins over 200 yards often provide better value for larger projects. Don’t overlook pack sizes—multi-pack purchases typically cost less per skein than individual ones.
Factor in shipping costs when comparing stores. Higher-priced yarn with free shipping can sometimes beat cheaper options with hefty delivery fees. Look for discounts, promotions, and loyalty programs that enhance your purchasing power.
Read customer reviews carefully about yarn quality. That bargain-priced skein might lack the softness or durability you need, ultimately costing you more in replacements. Balance price against quality to guarantee you’re getting genuine value.
Shipping Costs and Speed
How quickly do you need that yarn in your hands? Shipping speed matters, especially when you’re working against project deadlines. Standard delivery typically ranges from a few days to over a week, depending on processing times and your chosen method.
Compare shipping costs carefully between stores—fees vary markedly. Many retailers offer free shipping once you reach certain order thresholds, which can offset higher yarn prices. If time is critical, look for expedited shipping options, though they’ll cost extra.
Geography plays a role in delivery speed. Retailers closer to your location generally ship faster than distant ones. Before committing to a store, read customer reviews about their shipping experiences. These firsthand accounts reveal whether a retailer consistently delivers on time and handles packages properly.
Return and Exchange Policies
Before clicking that purchase button, examine the store’s return and exchange policies—they’re your safety net when colors look different in person or fiber content doesn’t match your project. Look for retailers offering 30 to 90-day return windows, giving you adequate time to evaluate your purchase. Check whether you can exchange yarn for different colors or weights if your original selection doesn’t work out.
Pay attention to who covers return shipping costs—some stores offer free returns while others charge fees that can add up quickly. Be aware that sale or discounted yarns often have special conditions; some retailers exclude these items from their standard return policy. Clear, customer-friendly policies indicate a store’s commitment to your satisfaction.
Product Information Accuracy
Thorough product details separate trustworthy online yarn stores from frustrating ones. You’ll need accurate specifications including material composition, weight, length, and thickness to determine if the yarn suits your project. Care instructions matter considerably—you should know whether it’s machine washable, hand wash only, or requires specific temperatures before purchasing.
Gauge information for both knitting and crochet is essential, showing expected stitch and row counts with recommended needle or hook sizes. This prevents costly mistakes and project disappointments. Clear color descriptions help you choose between solids, variegated, or self-striping options confidently.
Customer reviews and ratings provide invaluable insights into yarn quality and performance. Real user experiences reveal how the yarn actually behaves during crafting and after washing, helping you make informed decisions.
Inventory and Stock Availability
A well-stocked online yarn store saves you from project delays and dye lot mismatches. Look for retailers offering diverse materials like acrylic, wool, and polyester across various weight categories, from CYC #4 medium/worsted to CYC #6 super bulky. Wide color selections guarantee you’ll find the perfect shade for your project.
Check if popular and trending yarns are readily available, as limited stock can halt your progress or force dye lot compromises. Review the store’s restocking policy—frequent updates indicate commitment to providing current colors and materials. Consider shops offering multipack options, which assure consistent dye lots for larger projects while saving money.
Read customer reviews about stock availability and fulfillment times. Positive feedback typically reflects reliable inventory management, guaranteeing you’ll receive your yarn promptly without unexpected stockouts.
Care Instructions Provided
Clear care instructions protect your investment and guarantee your finished projects maintain their beauty through years of use. When selecting an online yarn store, prioritize retailers that provide detailed washing and maintenance guidelines for each yarn type.
Different fibers demand specific care approaches. Wool and delicate blends typically require hand washing and air drying, while acrylic yarns usually tolerate machine washing and tumble drying. You’ll find some fibers resist fading and shrinking, whereas others prove more susceptible to damage under improper conditions.
Look for stores that specify water temperatures, drying methods, and whether bleach should be avoided. These details directly impact your project’s longevity through multiple washes and regular use. Complete care information helps you make informed purchasing decisions based on your lifestyle and maintenance preferences.
Brand Selection and Authenticity
When shopping for yarn online, you’ll reveal that brand reputation directly influences the quality and consistency of your materials. Select brands that consistently score above 4.5 out of 5 stars in customer reviews, as these ratings reflect reliable performance within the yarn community.
Prioritize brands that provide detailed information about yarn composition, care instructions, and tool compatibility. This transparency guarantees you’re getting exactly what your project needs. Look for country of origin disclosures, which often indicate superior craftsmanship and quality standards.
Choose manufacturers with certifications related to chemical safety and sustainability. These credentials demonstrate commitment to ethical production practices. Finally, verify brands offer dye lot consistency when purchasing multiple skeins—this prevents frustrating color variations that could compromise your finished project.